Sawmill Optimization Series · Part 0 — Intro

Lumber prices are still below their 2022 peak, while labor, electricity and gas costs stay above their 2020 levels. New equipment is the obvious lever, but it comes with long lead times and capital cost. There is a faster path that needs no purchase order: process optimization. This guide is the map.
If your margin looks tighter than it did a few years ago, you are not alone. The picture depends on the base year, so each statement below names its base: lumber prices fell after 2022 and are still below their peak; labor, electricity and gas costs stay above their 2020 levels (gas and electricity are below their 2022 peaks); financing is dearer than before 2022. Log costs are not measured here, only the risk to log supply.
Prices fell after the 2022 peak and have only partly recovered. Eurostat's producer price index for sawmilling and planing of wood (EU27, 2021 = 100) peaked at 122.6 in May 2022, fell to 98.4 in November 2023 (−19.7%) and stood at 117.4 in August 2026, still 4.2% below the peak. The index covers all species and the domestic market, so it shows direction, not your own price list. Eurostat flags the values from December 2023 on, including August 2026, with i: “value imputed by Eurostat or other receiving agencies”.
Energy is still well above 2020. For EU non-household consumers (excluding VAT) the electricity price in the band of 2,000–19,999 MWh a year was €0.107/kWh in the second half of 2020, €0.202 in the second half of 2022 and €0.156 in the first half of 2026, about 45% above 2020 and about 23% below the second half of 2022. The gas price in the band of 10,000–99,999 GJ went from €0.028/kWh to €0.087 and then €0.062 on the same dates, about 2.2 times the 2020 level and about 29% below the second half of 2022.
Labor costs keep rising. Eurostat's hourly labour cost in EU manufacturing was €28.7 in 2020 and €35.0 in 2025, an increase of 22%.
Log supply is under pressure from forest disturbances. A study of more than 170,000 records from 34 European countries found that natural disturbances (wind, fire, bark beetles) have increased since 1950; over the last 20 years they accounted on average for 16% of the mean annual harvest in Europe, and the bark-beetle share of the damage doubled (Patacca et al., 2022).
Financing is more expensive than before 2022. The ECB's main refinancing rate was 0.00% from March 2016 to July 2022, peaked at 4.50% in September 2023 and has been 2.65% since 16 September 2026 (ECB key interest rates). Policy rates are not your bank's lending rate, but they set the direction of the cost of capital in a CapEx case.
The result for many mills is a cost-per-cubic-meter problem that running more shifts does not fix.
When margin compresses, two paths open. They look like alternatives. They aren't. They sit on completely different timelines.
The CapEx path. New equipment — a faster sorting line, a CT scanner, an additional kiln, a new edger optimizer. The mechanics are real. The problem is the calendar, and lead times differ by project and supplier. As a planning assumption of our own (not an industry benchmark): scoping 2–4 months, procurement 2–6, installation and ramp-up 3–6, together 7–16 months (2+2+3 to 4+6+6) from the decision to steady state. Higher financing rates stretch the payback case further. Assumption, not a measured figure.
The process optimization path. The same equipment you already own, run differently. Cut decisions matched more carefully to the order book. Sorting classes narrowed. Kiln charges rebuilt to fill the chamber. Order specs consolidated where customer tolerances allow. None of this requires a purchase order. Changes can start with the next production plan, and the margin effect shows up in the shipments that follow, not in the next budget cycle.
The honest comparison is not "CapEx or nothing." It's "process optimization first, then CapEx where the bottleneck has actually moved." Most sawmills have not yet exhausted the process optimization runway. That's what this guide is about.
The rest of this article does three things:
By the end you'll know where your biggest opportunity sits, what to measure to confirm it, and where to start.
A sawmill is a chain of six connected processes. The effects of the levers compound: every lever depends on the quality of the one before it. Speeding up sawing while sorting is loose just produces more bad cants. Tightening sorting while planning is reactive just makes inventory pile up. The order matters.
The map below is the navigator for the rest of this series. We'll walk through each lever briefly here, with practical actions and the sources we could check. Each lever has a dedicated deep-dive article that follows.
The optimization conversation usually starts at the saw. It should start at the order entry desk. By the time a log enters the line, the headroom is already largely fixed by the structure of the order book the planner is given to work with.
Three commercial practices change the economics of every shift downstream:
Take volumes that are multiples of the kiln package. If your standard package for 22×100 with 25 mm stickers is 4.0 × 1.2 × 1.2 m, then orders sized in package multiples drop straight into the kiln plan. Orders that aren't sized to the package leave half-empty packs or trigger ad-hoc rework — both bleed kiln capacity, and in many mills the kiln is the bottleneck. Example dimensions; use your own package.
Consolidate adjacent specs within customer tolerance. A 22×100 order and a 20×98 order may look like two specs. If both customers operate to a standard that allows ±2 mm (an example; check the contract, or for softwood sawn timber the permitted deviations in EN 1313-1), they're one spec. Run them together as 22×100. Result: fewer pattern changes on the line, larger production batches, simpler kiln planning, less work for the technologist. The customer gets exactly what their spec allows. The mill saves the setup time of every changeover avoided. Example values, not a recommendation to use ±2 mm.
Account for machine constraints before committing the order. The most expensive way to learn that an order doesn't fit your equipment is on the morning it's scheduled to run. Two examples that come up routinely:
If commerce sets the headroom, planning decides how much of it you actually capture. The direction is supported by simulation work: in a study on pruned radiata pine with three order books, planning the sawing against the orders (product optimization) needed fewer logs to satisfy all demand than optimizing volume or value alone, and under-production was eliminated (Todoroki & Rönnqvist, 2002). It is a simulation on one species, so it shows the direction, not the size of the effect. Planning is also the lever that most often lives in spreadsheets and in one technologist's head.
The core idea is simple, and most planners feel it intuitively without having a formal way to act on it:
Don't match one order to one log diameter. Pull a larger pool of available orders — for example roughly 1.5× the production volume of your planning window — and choose the optimal subset to run. With 1.0× of orders, you have no choice; every shift is a forced fit. With 1.5×, every shift can be assembled from the orders that fit your available log inventory best. The extra 0.5× isn't waste — those orders run next week, when the log inventory shifts. 1.5× is a rule of thumb, not a published benchmark.
Why 1.5× and not 1.2× or 2.0×? We could not find a published study that tests the size of the pool, so treat the number as a starting point. The reasoning is simple: with a pool that is too small the planner has too few options and falls back to forced fits; with a pool that is too large, working capital is tied up in promised orders that can't be cleared in a reasonable horizon and customer service can suffer. Test it on your own order book by comparing the plans you get at different pool sizes. Reasoning and rule of thumb, not independent evidence.
A second planning practice that compounds with the order pool: plan against a real yield model, not against rules of thumb. "We always run 72×144 for 180 mm logs" is a rule of thumb. The yield model says: for this batch of 180 mm logs, this set of available orders, and this kiln pipeline downstream, here are the three best cant patterns ranked by yield × order coverage. The technologist still chooses. But they choose with numbers, not memory. Example dimensions.
SawmillSmart is sawmill planning software built for this step. According to its product overview and how it works pages, it works in three ways that map to failure modes of manual planning:
The arithmetic behind 5 percentage points, as an illustration separate from the case: on 140,000 m³ of logs a year, 5 percentage points of yield are 140,000 × 0.05 = 7,000 m³ of additional sawn timber a year. Illustrative calculation, not a measured result.
For orientation only: the FAO, ITTO and UNECE conversion-factor tables give a median of 1.81 m³ of roundwood per m³ of coniferous sawnwood in Europe, about 55% (1 / 1.81), and stress that the factor depends on the state of the product (green, dried, edged, planed). Compare yield figures only on the same basis (FAO/ITTO/UNECE, 2020).
Planning sets the strategy. Log sorting decides whether the strategy can actually be executed. The sorting station is rarely the most glamorous part of the sawmill — and it is a common place where ambitious yield plans go to die.
Three sorting practices to check:
Match the class width to the sawing pattern. Logs are sorted into sawing classes by top diameter, normally in intervals of 10 to 20 mm, and each class gets patterns sized for its smallest log: to get centre boards with sharp edges along the whole log, the diagonal of the sawing pattern must be smaller than the lower limit of the class (Lundahl, 2009). In a simulation of one Swedish sawline, optimizing the width and position of the classes raised the true volume yield from 49.3% to 51.6% (same doctoral thesis). That is one simulated mill and one pine log population, and the gain came from width and position together, so it does not tell you what a move from 2 cm to 1 cm is worth in your mill.
The rule as arithmetic, for one example cant: a 72×144 mm cant has a diagonal of √(72² + 144²) = 161 mm, and about 167 mm with the 4% allowance for sawing deviations and shrinkage used in the thesis (161 × 1.04). No log in its class may then be below about 167 mm top diameter. In a 10 mm class starting at 167 mm the average log is 5 mm larger than the pattern was sized for; in a 20 mm class it is 10 mm larger, and that extra diameter is not used by the pattern. Illustrative example for one cant; not a measurement.
Build a buffer of sorted logs ahead of sawing. Without a buffer, planning collapses to "what's in the yard right now." With sorted inventory across all diameter classes — weeks rather than days of sawing, depending on your yard — the planner can choose which diameter to run on a given shift to match the order pool, instead of being forced to run whatever just got sorted. Keep the sorting line ahead of the saw, even when it feels like overkill.
Two sub-rules that operators learn the hard way:
The saw line is loud and visible. Its losses are usually quiet and hard to see. The big two: changeovers between cant patterns, and forced cross-section variety beyond what the line can sort.
Minimize cant-pattern changeovers per shift. Every change of sawing class and pattern stops the saw. A Swedish doctoral thesis reports 5 to 15 minutes of setup time per change of sawing class at the mill it studied, depending on the sawline, and notes that classes are changed during breaks whenever possible (Lundahl, 2009). At the top of that range, six changes in an 8-hour shift take 6 × 15 = 90 minutes, 19% of the 480-minute shift (90 / 480). Most of those changes are imposed by upstream choices: a planner trying to clear too many specs in one shift, or commerce that delivered too many similar-but-not-identical orders that should have been consolidated. The fix is mostly in Levers 1 and 2.
Minimize diameter changes within a shift. Every diameter change implies a sort buffer reset, often a saw alignment check, sometimes a feed speed change. Same logic — the fix is in planning.
Don't run more cross-sections than your sort capacity can handle. A simple rule of thumb: count your sorting pockets after the saw. Subtract one for waste. Divide the rest by 3 (allowing for grade splits per cross-section). The result is roughly the maximum number of cross-sections you can run cleanly per setup. With 10 pockets: 1 waste, 9 ÷ 3 = 3 cross-sections. Pushing this to 5 cross-sections forces grade-mixing in pockets, which means slower sorting downstream, more rework, lost grade premium. The sawing speed gain is illusory. Rule of thumb and example numbers, not a published standard.
In some mills the kilns are the constraint of the whole operation: when Södra ordered two new kilns for its Värö sawmill in Sweden in 2019, the mill manager called the drying kilns "currently a bottleneck in sawmill production" (Global Wood Markets Info, 2019). A kiln whose individual charges are loaded below the design volume wastes exactly the capacity that is scarce.
The opportunity is geometric, not chemical. Three rules:
Load to the design volume, not to package count. The kiln has a fixed cubic volume. The pack count tells you nothing about utilization if packs are different sizes, so measure load as the volume of timber in the chamber against the design (capacity) load. The USDA Forest Products Laboratory kiln manual is explicit that overloading and underloading change air circulation and with it drying time and quality, and it calls adding an extra tier of packages to gain capacity poor practice because it narrows the plenum and makes airflow nonuniform (Simpson, 1991, ch. 5).
What a full charge is worth, as arithmetic: if the average charge is loaded to 80% of the design volume and you bring it to 95%, each charge carries 95 / 80 = 1.19 times as much timber, about 19% more, with the same number of cycles. Hypothetical starting point of 80%; no published benchmark for how full commercial kilns run.
Package width and height must match the kiln cross-section. Gaps in, around, over or under the load give air a path that bypasses the lumber, and the faster the air moves, the more it short-circuits through them. For single-track kilns the manual says the distance between the load and the top-load baffles should not exceed 4 in (about 10 cm) (Simpson, 1991, ch. 5). In one numerical model of a single kiln, three quarters of the airflow bypassed the wood stacks (Bedelean et al., 2016); that is a case study, not a general figure.
All packages in a charge should be the same thickness — or within minimal tolerance. Drying time rises more than in proportion to thickness: when thickness doubles it rises by roughly three to four times (about 3 to 3.5 in the schedule tables), and lumber of different thicknesses can't be dried in one charge without either prolonging the drying of the thin lumber or risking defects in the thick (Simpson, 1991, ch. 1, 6 and 7). In practice either some boards are over-dried (energy waste, value loss) or some are under-dried (rejected, regraded).
The dry sorting line is where the sawmill either acknowledges or papers over every prior-step decision. A well-planned, well-cut, well-dried board sorts cleanly and lands in the right grade. A board that drifted at any prior step shows up here as a downgrade.
The opportunities here are the last decisions on each board: better grade-recovery rules at the trimmer, smarter trim length decisions for grade, and tighter coordination with the order book so premium grades aren't trimmed down into commodity lengths to clear backlog. How much is at stake is documented mostly for hardwood: in a study of red oak boards from three mills, the mills' edging and trimming recovered 62–78% of the value that an optimization procedure obtained from the same boards (Regalado et al., 1992). We did not find a verified figure for softwood trimmers. Where the product is structural timber, strength grading follows EN 14081-1.
Levers tell you what to do. Principles tell you how to think about doing it. Without principles, any one of the six levers above turns into a one-off campaign — a yield committee that meets twice, an off-site that never converts to a process, a project that loses momentum the moment the consultant leaves.
These five principles separate sawmills that improve once from sawmills that keep improving.
What doesn't work: a planning process where the technologist holds the key model in their head, where Excel is the source of truth, where yield is reviewed at month-end, where last week's plan and this week's actual sit in different files that only one person can reconcile.
What works: a single source of truth that contains the predicted yield for each cant pattern, the actual yield by shift, and the structure of the open order book — visible to the technologist, the operations manager, and the commercial team on the same day.
The bar is lower than people fear. You don't need a real-time data lake or a sawmill twin. You need three things tied together: yield forecast, plan/actual reconciliation, and order book visibility — refreshed at least once per shift.
SawmillSmart fit: simulated recovery % per scenario and per cutting pattern is visible before the plan is confirmed, order-fulfilment progress is tracked against the plan, and the order book is visible inside the same tool the planner already uses (see the product overview). The plan is updated every shift, with at-risk order alerts.
Speeding up sawing while sorting is loose just produces more bad cants. Tightening sorting while planning is reactive just makes inventory pile up. Buying a faster trimmer when the kiln is the bottleneck just lets you build inventory in front of the bottleneck. Local-station optimization typically degrades the whole line — the bottleneck doesn't disappear, it moves.
Before any local improvement, ask: where is the constraint right now, and does this change move it somewhere better, or just somewhere else? In many sawmills the constraint sits in commerce or planning (Levers 1 and 2), but find yours first. Optimizing anything else first is rearranging the deck chairs.
A buffer of sorted logs plus a multi-week production plan is a different economy from "we'll figure tomorrow out tomorrow." Same-day planning is reactive. Yield gains aren't reachable from a reactive posture, because the planner has no degrees of freedom — they're just keeping the line fed.
The horizon makes the order pool work. The order pool makes pattern selection work. Pattern selection is where yield comes from. The whole stack collapses if the planning horizon shrinks.
SawmillSmart is sawmill planning software that works on a planning window, not the shift: a rolling four-week horizon (see the product overview). The planner loads the orders, the log assortment (species, diameter, length, count) and the sawline capacities and shift structure. The system evaluates cut patterns, production allocation and sequencing across the whole window — not just for the next shift in isolation.
That horizon is what makes a larger order pool from Lever 2 workable. Without it, the planner is back to fitting one order to one cant on whatever logs happen to be at the front of the buffer this morning. A frozen zone protects the shifts that are already committed, and the plan updates as orders, inventory or line conditions change — the default starting point is a horizon-optimized plan, not a shift-by-shift fire drill.
Homogenize: "we run only a few specs, take it or leave it." Customer service collapses. Order book shrinks. The mill ends up running the wrong product for whatever market it's left with.
Standardize: combine adjacent specs within customer tolerance so the line runs simpler — without losing the customer. The customer gets exactly what their tolerance allows. The mill saves changeover time. Both win. The work is in the salesperson having the conversation up front to get the tolerance acknowledged in writing on the order.
This is the difference between a mill that reduces specs by saying no, and a mill that reduces specs by saying yes more cleverly.
Any optimization conversation without a metric is a difference of opinion. The argument about whether the sort step matters, whether the kiln is "really" full, whether the planner's estimate is reasonable — all dissolve when you have measurements.
The minimum metric set every sawmill should have visible:
If you can't see all five at the start of the day on Monday, that's where the optimization program starts.
The hardest part of sawmill optimization is starting. Below are five diagnostic questions any operator can answer in an afternoon. Each one points to a concrete next action. Pick the one that surfaces the biggest gap and move on it this week.
SawmillSmart is sawmill planning software for planning teams: it plans over a rolling four-week horizon, simulates yield for each scenario and tracks order fulfilment against the plan.
Anonymized result, one line: same logs, same crew, same line — net yield from 46% to 51% in one quarter. Company data from a real SawmillSmart customer mill, not an independent study. SawmillSmart’s own average estimate is 2–4% (the unit is not defined on the product page); this mill’s result is above that average.
This guide is the intro. Each lever has a dedicated deep-dive article — published over the coming weeks of the series.
Numbers in this guide are linked to the source they come from, or marked as a rule of thumb, an assumption, an illustrative example or company data. Theses and degree projects are labelled as such. Where a publisher page would not open, only the abstract (via OpenAlex or Crossref) was read.
Anonymized client case data referenced in this article is based on real project results from a European softwood sawmill engagement. Specific company identification has been omitted to preserve commercial confidentiality. Source of the case: anonymised data from a real SawmillSmart customer mill (company data). Other examples and calculations in this guide are illustrative; rules of thumb and assumptions are marked where they appear.