- What yield is: lumber volume per log volume. Most of the gain comes from deciding how each log is cut, before the saw runs.
- What studies report: simulated gains of 13% (Balboni et al. (2023)) and up to 24% (Stängle et al. (2015)), and a project-reported value yield gain of at least 5 percentage points (Vinnova project “Improved sawing, part 2”). The Vinnova project “More timber – less saw dust” only set a target of 2 percentage points. None of these is a guarantee for your line.
- Why it matters: raw material is 40–60% of product cost in hardwood rough mills (Thomas & Buehlmann (2016)) and about 70% of total costs for most sawmills (Vinnova project “More timber – less saw dust”).
- A common claim, corrected: “1% more yield = 2% lower total cost” is a potential saving from a hardwood rough-mill paper. With logs at 70% of cost, a 1% relative gain saves about 0.7%.
- Cost and payback: no independent payback figures for small mills were found. Use the lumber recovery calculator and the ROI calculator on your own numbers.
| Way to raise yield | Reported effect (source) | Cost | When it pays back |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plan cuts against the order book over several weeks | 2–4% average yield gain versus shift-by-shift planning: SawmillSmart’s own estimate (product page), not an independent study | Subscription, quoted per mill; no new equipment | No independent figure. Estimate with the ROI calculator |
| Choose the cutting pattern per log instead of one fixed scheme | Project-reported value yield gain of at least 5 percentage points with new free sawing patterns (Vinnova project “Improved sawing, part 2”, Luleå University of Technology, 2020–2023) | Needs optimization software and a saw line that can follow the pattern; no price verified | No independent figure |
| Rotate each log to its best angle using CT-scanned internal knots | Up to 24% higher volume and value yield than the average angle, simulated on 33 beech logs (Stängle et al. (2015)) | CT scanning is a large capital purchase; no price verified | No published payback found for small mills |
| Accept more wane and random-width boards for engineered wood products | Simulated recovery +11% (wane), +2% (random widths), +13% combined, for a South African log-size mix; simulation overestimated real recovery by 2.1% (Balboni et al. (2023)) | Needs a buyer or line for engineered wood products; no cost verified | Depends on the outlet price |
Logs are the largest cost in a sawmill, so the share of each log that leaves as lumber decides much of the margin. This article answers the questions sawmill owners ask about how to increase sawmill yield: what the studies report, what a 1% gain is worth, what it costs and how to test it on your own mill. Every number carries a source; where we found none, the text says so.
Table of Contents
- How can a sawmill increase lumber yield?
- What is a good lumber recovery factor?
- What is a 1% yield gain worth?
- What yield gains do studies report?
- Does cutting optimization software raise yield?
- How much does yield optimization cost?
- Is a log scanner worth it for a small mill?
- Frequently asked questions
How can a sawmill increase lumber yield?
A sawmill raises lumber yield by deciding better how each log is cut and by wasting less in the cut itself: choosing the sawing pattern per log and per order, keeping saw accuracy and kerf under control, and planning against the order book over weeks instead of shifts. Published gains range from a few percentage points to double digits.
Yield is decided in a few places. The first is the cutting decision: with a given log (diameter, length, taper, sweep) and a given set of orders, many sawing patterns are possible, and the best one is not always the one that comes first to mind. Spreadsheets and rules of thumb cover only a small part of that choice, which is why we compare them with dedicated tools in Excel versus sawmill planning software.
The second is the cut itself: kerf, saw accuracy and sorting. The lumber recovery calculator uses default kerf widths of 3 mm for a band saw, 4 mm for a frame saw and 5.5 mm for a circular saw to show how much of a log leaves as sawdust. The third is planning: matching logs to the order book over several weeks, covered in how planning horizon affects lumber recovery. For the full list of levers, see what sawmill optimization actually means.
What is a good lumber recovery factor?
Lumber recovery factor (LRF) is the board feet of lumber a mill gets from one cubic foot of log; the arithmetic ceiling is 12. A Keegan et al. (2010) study of western US mills found 8.67 in Oregon and 8.43 in Washington. Metric yield is lumber m³ over log m³. No single figure is “good”: diameter, taper and kerf move it.
The 8.67 and 8.43 figures are for western US softwood mills that use the Scribner log rule, which is why the authors prefer LRF to the older “overrun” measure: LRF is based on the cubic volume of solid wood in the log. They are a reference point, not a target for a European mill. For metric mills the same idea is lumber m³ divided by log m³, which the lumber recovery calculator estimates for a single log and cutting pattern.
Compare your own yield against your own history by log diameter class and product mix. A mill that tracks recovery per diameter class can see where it loses most, which a single average hides.
What is a 1% yield gain worth?
If logs are about 70% of a sawmill’s costs, as a Swedish university project (Vinnova project “More timber – less saw dust”) reports, a 1% relative gain in recovery cuts log input by about 1% and total cost by about 0.7%. The popular “2% per 1%” rule comes from a hardwood rough-mill paper (Thomas & Buehlmann (2016)) and is a potential saving in that setting, not a sawmill benchmark.
Take a mill that buys €10 million of logs a year and holds its lumber output constant. A 1% relative gain in recovery means 1% less log for the same output: about €99,000 saved (€10M × (1 − 1/1.01)). A 3% gain saves about €291,000. If yield rises from 50% to 51%, that is a 2% relative gain and about €196,000.
The share of total cost this represents depends on how large logs are in your cost base. Thomas & Buehlmann (2016) cite lumber at 40–60% of product cost in hardwood rough mills, and the Vinnova project “More timber – less saw dust” puts raw material at about 70% of total costs for most sawmills. Use your own figure: your log cost divided by your total cost.
What yield gains do studies report?
Studies report simulated gains of 13% and up to 24%, plus at least 5 percentage points in one research project (another only set a 2-point target). All rest on specific assumptions about species, log sizes and prices. Treat them as upper bounds to test on your own logs, not as forecasts; real gains depend on how good your current cutting decisions are.
- Flexible sawing. The Vinnova project “Improved sawing, part 2” reports that new free sawing patterns raised value yield by at least five percentage points. Forghani et al. (2024) study flexible sawing and product grading based on wane and log shape.
- Log rotation with CT. Stängle et al. (2015) virtually sawed 33 European beech logs at 12 rotation angles; the best angle per log raised volume and value yield by up to 24% over the average angle. The authors call it a small-scale study, and 24% is the best case.
- Engineered wood outlets. Balboni et al. (2023) simulated sawing with higher wane and random board widths. The result for a South African log-size mix was +11% recovery from wane, +2% from random widths and +13% combined; against real sawing, the simulation overestimated volume recovery by 2.1%.
- Background. Nasir et al. (2024) review where digital tools fit in lumber production (“Sawmill 4.0”), without a single yield number to quote.
Percentage points and percent are not the same thing. Lifting yield from 50% to 51% is one percentage point but a 2% relative gain, so check which one a source means before multiplying it by your log bill.
Does cutting optimization software raise yield?
Optimization software searches many cutting combinations against your logs, orders and machine limits and picks the best plan. It needs log data (species, diameter, length, count), orders or a demand plan, and sawline parameters. The gain depends on how good your current planning is, so ask for a simulation on your own data.
Before software, the cutting plan came from the sawyer’s experience. A computer can evaluate far more combinations in seconds, which is the core of cutting optimization (the sawmill optimization guide covers the full set of levers). Nasir et al. (2024) give an overview of the tools of intelligent lumber production, and the layers of sawmill optimization are explained in a separate guide.
What SawmillSmart does. SawmillSmart is a web-based planning application. It takes your log assortment, your orders or demand plan and your sawline parameters (how it works), evaluates thousands of cutting combinations per run and plans over a multi-week horizon, with a rolling four-week plan (product overview). Each simulation returns ranked scenarios with recovery %, m³ processed and production cost, and orders can be imported from Excel. It needs no new equipment on the line. The 2–4% average gain on the product page is our own estimate against shift-by-shift planning, not an independent study; ask for a simulation on your own data.
How much does yield optimization cost?
It depends on the route. Process changes such as sorting, pattern choice and saw maintenance cost mostly time. Planning software is priced by mill size and scope: SawmillSmart quotes per mill on request (pricing). Scanners and optimizers are capital purchases; this article does not quote prices because no vendor-independent figures were verified.
SawmillSmart plans range from digital inventory only (Starter) through a yield optimization engine (Advanced) to automated production-plan generation (Professional) and a customised Enterprise plan; each is priced as a tailored proposal on the pricing page. Two free tools help to size the case before any purchase: the lumber recovery calculator and the ROI calculator.
Is a log scanner worth it for a small mill?
We found no verifiable published payback figure for small mills. Work it out yourself: equipment cost divided by (extra output × margin per unit − added running cost). Test recovery gains of 2%, 5% and 10% against your own log costs. Check kerf, saw accuracy and pattern choice first with the lumber recovery calculator.
The evidence we could verify is about hardwood CT scanning (the Stängle et al. (2015) simulation above) and says nothing about payback. We did not find a published payback study for small mills, and we do not quote vendor figures here. For your own case:
- Take the added lumber volume from a recovery gain of 2%, 5% and 10% on your yearly log input.
- Multiply by your margin per unit of lumber, and subtract added running costs.
- Divide the equipment price by that yearly gain.
Ask any scanner vendor for before-and-after recovery data from a mill of your size.
Frequently asked questions
How can a sawmill increase lumber yield?
A sawmill raises lumber yield by deciding better how each log is cut and by wasting less in the cut itself: choosing the sawing pattern per log and per order, keeping saw accuracy and kerf under control, and planning against the order book over weeks instead of shifts. Published gains range from a few percentage points to double digits.
What is a good lumber recovery factor?
Lumber recovery factor (LRF) is the board feet of lumber a mill gets from one cubic foot of log; the arithmetic ceiling is 12. A 2010 study of western US mills found 8.67 in Oregon and 8.43 in Washington. Metric yield is lumber m³ over log m³. No single figure is “good”: diameter, taper and kerf move it.
What is a 1% yield gain worth?
If logs are about 70% of a sawmill’s costs, as a Swedish university project reports, a 1% relative gain in recovery cuts log input by about 1% and total cost by about 0.7%. The popular “2% per 1%” rule comes from a hardwood rough-mill paper and is a potential saving in that setting, not a sawmill benchmark.
How much does yield optimization cost?
It depends on the route. Process changes such as sorting, pattern choice and saw maintenance cost mostly time. Planning software is priced by mill size and scope: SawmillSmart quotes per mill on request. Scanners and optimizers are capital purchases; this article does not quote prices because no vendor-independent figures were verified.
Is a log scanner worth it for a small mill?
We found no verifiable published payback figure for small mills. Work it out yourself: equipment cost divided by (extra output × margin per unit − added running cost). Test recovery gains of 2%, 5% and 10% against your own log costs. Check kerf, saw accuracy and pattern choice first with the lumber recovery calculator.
Related Articles
- Sawmill Optimization Guide 2026: 6 Levers and 5 Principles to Recover Margin Without CapEx
- What Sawmill Optimization Actually Means — a layer-by-layer breakdown of where yield gains come from
- Excel vs. Sawmill Planning Software — the specific cost of spreadsheet-based production planning
- Sawmill Software Compared: 5 Types of Digital Systems
- How Planning Horizon Affects Lumber Recovery Outcomes
Sources
- Thomas, R.E., & Buehlmann, U. (2016). Potential for yield improvement in combined rip-first and crosscut-first rough mill processing. BioResources, 11(1), 1477–1493. bioresources.cnr.ncsu.edu
- Luleå University of Technology / Vinnova (2008–2011). More timber – less saw dust. vinnova.se
- Luleå University of Technology / Vinnova (2020–2023). Improved sawing, part 2. vinnova.se
- Stängle, S.M., Brüchert, F., Heikkila, A., Usenius, T., Usenius, A., & Sauter, U.H. (2015). Potentially increased sawmill yield from hardwoods using X-ray computed tomography for knot detection. Annals of Forest Science, 72, 57–65. doi:10.1007/s13595-014-0385-1
- Balboni, B.M., Chatukuta, S.T., Muller, B., & Wessels, C.B. (2023). The sawmill yield increase potential with manufacturing increased wane and random width boards for engineered wood products. Wood Material Science & Engineering, 19(1), 160–167. doi:10.1080/17480272.2023.2229279
- Forghani, K., Carlsson, M., Flener, P., Fredriksson, M., Pearson, J., & Yuan, D. (2024). Maximizing value yield in wood industry through flexible sawing and product grading based on wane and log shape. Computers and Electronics in Agriculture, 216. doi:10.1016/j.compag.2023.108513
- Nasir, V., Rahimi, S., Mohammadpanah, A., Hansen, E., & Sassani, F. (2024). Intelligent Lumber Production (Sawmill 4.0): Opportunities, Challenges, and Pathways to Adoption. In: Integrated Systems: Data Driven Engineering, Springer, 213–231. doi:10.1007/978-3-031-53652-6_13
- Keegan, C.E., Morgan, T.A., Blatner, K.A., & Daniels, J. (2010). Trends in lumber processing in the Western United States. Part II: Overrun and lumber recovery factors. Forest Products Journal, 60(2), 140–143. research.fs.usda.gov
